The uncanny parallels
08/30/2020
I try to keep this blog free of politics, but the last few weeks have brought out a series of very alarming parallels between the current situation in America and that in pre-Civil War Spain.
As Stanley G. Payne pointed out in great detail in his Spanish Civil War, by 1935 the Spanish Left reached a point where it believed that no other party should be allowed to govern Spain. This repudiated the constitution that they themselves had written only recently.
Time and again, they broke laws, ignored customs and always chose to escalate rather than calm. Payne goes through an entire checklist of "off ramps" the Left ignored, any one of which could have avoided the resulting carnage of war.
The fact of the matter is that it is difficult to push a war on people who don't want one. The Man of Destiny series was written in calmer times, but I recognized that one of the fatal flaws in the Star Wars prequels was how arbitrary and random the start of the Clone War was.
Thus when I began telling my story, I spent all of the first book and half of the second chronicling the downward spiral, including opportunities for both sides to de-escalate.
All historical parallels are inexact and one can rightly note that the standard of living, technology, international reach of modern American cannot be compared with that of Spain in 1936.
Still, I cannot deny that part of the frenzy that drove me to write Long Live Death was a desire to get out in front of events and supply the book as a cautionary tale. Spain's leaders in 1936 did not have many examples of how a seemingly united and peaceful society can disintegrate into conflict. We do, with not just Spain but the breakdown of Yugoslavia serving as grim reminders that the bonds that keep nations together can collapse with frightful speed.
I will conclude by asking those of a religious bent to include a plea for reconciliation, forgiveness and renewed unity in your prayers. We need all the help we can get.
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.