Movie anti-review: Dune
03/09/2024
It's been a while since I did an anti-review, and many readers may not know what that is. An anti-review is where I take a movie I might have wanted to see and explain why I'm not going to see it. A lot of the new Star Wars films got anti-reviews.
Dune is getting an anti-review for several reasons. The biggest is that this is the third film adaptation of the books and I'm just not that interested in the topic. As far as I am concerned, the Sci-Fi Channel's miniseries was pretty definitive. Yes, it had poor special effects and some of the action was sub-par, but it did a good job of conveying the content of the books and the general weirdness of Frank Herbert's landmark novels.
While the current films are being lauded, I've read that corners were cut in order to fit the story into a cinematic format. This kills what little curiosity I have left. Dune works - and was successful despite terrible writing - because of how Herbert was able to (for the most part) bring everything together at the end. That makes it very difficult to film.
I'm going to add another reason completely unrelated to the rest and that is that I'm sick of remakes and reboots. As I said, there are already two other versions of the same material. There are now three versions of Avatar: The Last Airbender. The lack of creativity is absurd.
Godzilla: Minus One took a familiar franchise and gave it a new, unique and captivating twist. One doesn't have to start from scratch to make something fresh and exciting.
More and more, I'm just going back to the originals. I'm also continuing to explore films I've overlooked, of which there are many. Life is too short to watch derivative trash.
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.